
AM Best revises Hagerty Re outlook to stable despite capital gains
AM Best has revised Hagerty Reinsurance’s outlook to stable from positive, citing uncertainty around future capital positions following changes to management’s capital deployment plans, despite continued improvements in capitalisation and strong underwriting performance.
AM Best affirmed the financial strength rating of A- and long-term issuer credit rating of “a-” of Hagerty Re, based in Hamilton, Bermuda, and its reinsured affiliate, Drivers Edge Insurance Company, based in Littleton, Colorado. Both companies are wholly owned subsidiaries of Hagerty Insurance Holdings.
The ratings reflect Hagerty Re’s strong balance sheet strength, strong operating performance, neutral business profile and appropriate enterprise risk management (ERM), according to AM Best.
The rating agency said Hagerty Re’s surplus had grown rapidly in recent years, supported by strong underwriting margins, increased quota shares on favourable business and, more recently, robust net investment income from a more diversified but conservative investment portfolio.
However, revised capital plans allowing for more opportunistic deployment of capital across the wider Hagerty brands ecosystem have introduced uncertainty around future capital positions, prompting the change in outlooks despite the improvement in risk-adjusted capitalisation.
Hagerty Re has diversified its investment portfolio over the past two years, moving beyond its historically heavy allocation to cash and cash equivalents. The changes have generated stronger investment income while keeping overall investment risk within the company’s risk tolerances.
AM Best assessed Hagerty Re’s operating performance as strong, citing combined ratios consistently below personal auto peer averages. Its underwriting profitability is supported by specialist underwriting and vehicle valuation expertise, claims handling capabilities, a network of collector vehicle repair experts, a special investigation unit and dedicated parts finders.
The company’s business profile was assessed as neutral, reflecting its position as a niche writer focused on enthusiast vehicles, despite strong brand recognition in the segment and partnerships with some of the world’s largest auto insurers.
Its specialist data and expertise, supported by relationships with specialist auto repair businesses and replacement parts suppliers, underpin these partnerships.
Hagerty Re has also expanded its international presence through the recent acquisition of UK-based specialist motorcycle insurance broker Bennetts.
AM Best assessed the company’s ERM as appropriate for its size and scope, highlighting its management processes, stress-testing scenarios and risk mitigation plans. Its use of reinsurance remains modest but strategic, supporting capital efficiency.
Drivers Edge benefits from a 100% quota share agreement with Hagerty Re, common ownership and the assignment of Hagerty Re’s managing general agents to generate business.
Did you get value from this story? Sign up to our free newsletters and get stories like this sent straight to your inbox.
